Cold Case Files

Television crime shows are often built around unsolved murders. Detectives re-visit old case files and talk to witnesses and likely perps again and again until they're successful. Of course they don't make television shows about the unsuccessful cases, of which, nationally, there are thousands upon thousands.

But three cases here in Mendocino County can and should be pursued but aren't being pursued:

(1) Katlyn Long

Katlyn Long’s Suspicious Death

by Tim Stelloh (AVA, April 19, 2010)

The last few months of Katlyn Long’s abbreviated life unfolded much like anyone transitioning between relationships: Unhappy with her long-term, 31-year-old boyfriend, Long broke things off. The 22-year-old Fort Bragg girl had met someone else—someone who, friends say, seemed to make her happy.

She left California with her new boyfriend early last year, but work obligations brought her back home for what was to be a brief visit. That fateful trip back would be her last: In the early morning of May 29, after spending the night with her ex-boyfriend, she was hauled to Mendocino Coast Hospital in an ambulance without a pulse—the victim of a methadone overdose.

Yet it wasn’t until last week that police revealed her cause of death. No charges have been filed.

The way detectives explain it, the one eyewitness in the case has exercised his right to remain silent since Long’s death. That eyewitness, of course, is Long’s ex, Garett Matson, son of ex-Fort Bragg planning commissioner and businessman Jerry Matson. Police say that over the course of that year they were negotiating with Matson’s attorney, Richard Petersen, in an attempt to get a statement. To maintain the apparently delicate balance of those negotiations, investigators commenced the media chess game: They withheld the results of a toxicology report completed last July that examined Long’s blood and found that she had overdosed. They kept a lid on all but the most public details of the girl’s death--namely, that she had died “suspiciously.” And they told the media the eyewitness was Long’s ex-boyfriend--but they declined to name the ex.

Petersen, of course, tells it differently. He says he’s offered to answer written questions from the police--but he wouldn’t subject Matson to a prosecutorial-style inquiry because he’s “suffering terrible emotional problems.”

“We can't open him up because he feels very threatened and weak right now,” Petersen said, summarizing what he says are a doctor's orders. “What people say about him breaks his heart.” In the unlikely event detectives share the forensic evidence they’ve collected on Matson, Petersen said he’d change his tune.

“I’d turn my client over,” he said.

In the meantime, Petersen sent a seven page statement to the DA’s office last month--a statement he described as a “timed list” of the days leading up to Long’s death. (Neither he nor the Sheriff’s office would share specifics of the statement.) And last week, detectives released an outline of what happened, along with the results of the toxicology report.

Yet it’s still unclear how--or why--that lethal dose of methadone ended up in Long’s blood.

The synthetic opiate, long thought of as a drug for junkies kicking their heroin habit, has taken on a different role in recent years as a cheap, non-narcotic prescription pain killer. As methadone prescriptions have spiked, so has the number of methadone overdoses: The drug can be lethal when combined, say, with alcohol, or when taken in too great a quantity, as its effects are far shorter than the time it stays in the body.

Sheriff’s Lt. Rusty Noe said Long didn’t have a prescription for methadone, nor did detectives find any evidence that she was using it as a pain killer. Friends say she was the last person they would expect to use such drugs recreationally. “She was like apple pie,” said Jeanne Huckins, who shared Long’s affinity for horses and rode with her often. “One time she came to the stable and she was babbling on and on and on, and I said, ‘Katlyn, what are you on?’ and she said ‘Red Bull.’ … She was very sensitive to that kind of stuff.”

Katlyn & Rosie

Matson, on the other hand, has a history of prior drug charges. A several year old letter from neighbors in Matson’s court file even described his home as a well known crank house that police visited often: “For two years Matson has terrorized the neighborhood with shootings, loud fights and low-life people coming and going at all hours, though mostly in the middle of the night,” the letter said. It went on to describe how he “unleashed” a vicious dog on a neighbor, sending the senior citizen to the hospital twice.

Those cases--which include discharging a firearm while under the influence of a controlled substance--were dismissed when Matson agreed to drug court. (Petersen said a person’s past is only “circumstantial evidence of what the future holds.”)

Huckins described the couple’s relationship as a troubled one—a relationship where Long felt suffocated by her ex and which she ended shortly before she died. She described how, in the months before her overdose, Long had started seeing a new boyfriend--a man named William Housley--who Huckins said had brightened Long’s mood considerably. They traveled together to Washington State to visit Housley’s parents. “She was having a wonderful time,” she said. “I noticed a real shift when she started hanging out with William. She was a happy person—instead of a person who was always crying and blaming herself, who would cut herself.”

Long returned to Fort Bragg last May, Huckins said, because she worked at the stable where she kept her horses and the owners were leaving town. While home, Matson tried to rekindle their relationship. But Long wasn’t interested. The afternoon before she died the two had an argument at Long’s parents house--an argument caused by Matson thinking the two were close to reuniting, Petersen said. Matson allegedly bashed in her car and left, but returned later that afternoon.

By 5 am the next morning she was dead.

Sheriff’s deputies, who had been summoned with the ambulance, noticed “suspicious” marks on her neck, so detectives were dispatched to investigate. The marks turned out to be unrelated to the cause of her death, and the rest is history.

Some of Long’s friends and supporters theorize that she was murdered. Petersen disagrees. “If she overdosed, he didn't do it. It was either accidental, or intentional on her part,” he said. “I don't know of any one who would have wanted to kill her--including Garett. But nobody wants to believe she committed suicide either.”

For now, no suspects have been named and the DA kicked the case back to the sheriff’s office, which says it’s an open investigation--though District Attorney Meredith Lintott said her investigators are still involved, as they are with most big murder cases. If the case does go to court, Lintott said, there’s no statute of limitations on murder, nor with manslaughter in most situations. It can be a different story with other, less serious charges, however.

“It’s very tricky. People go to court to litigate statute of limitations,” she said. “The whole case can be thrown out.”

So far, Long’s family has been mum on the matter--Katlyn’s mother, Linda Long, said in an e-mail that she didn’t want to compromise the case--as are several friends.

But that hasn’t stopped an online petition from being circulated; as of publication, the petition has nearly met its 1,000 signature goal. Once completed, the site says, it will be sent to the DA’s office because “…we want to show them that there are lots of citizens that will not rest until justice is served, and who will be watching this case.” Nor has it stopped thousands of posts from appearing on a forum attached to the Ukiah Daily Journal’s website. Unlike most message boards associated with controversial stories--where participants seem to revel in vulgar anonymity--this one is relatively benign: family and friends post poems; they give updates on the case; they talk about their freshly inked Katlyn tattoos.

Still, the site—like most message boards—has the air of judge, jury and executioner. And it ain’t a pretty verdict for Garett Matson.

* * *

(2) Susan Keegan

Crime show aficionados know that people are being prosecuted for murder all the time on a lot less evidence than exists in the Keegan case. (Available by googling Susan Keegan.) Mrs. Keegan was, quite probably, bludgeoned to death by her husband, Dr. Peter Keegan. We know that Tim Stoen of the DA's Fort Bragg office, and once consiglieri to Jim Jones, who's pushing 80 and has experienced serious medical problems, was assigned to the Keegan case, an assignment that would certainly draw even more outside attention to it than is inherent in a homicide case where the defendant is a medical doctor. Keegan should have been prosecuted years ago, Mrs. Keegan having breathed her last in November of 2010. DA Eyster is out of excuses on this one, although to be fair to Eyster, the Sheriff's Department badly screwed up the initial investigation and then, under the helter-skelter DA's regime of Meredith Lintott, there was no ongoing investigation. Eyster picked up the ball and is occasionally still seen stumbling downfield with it.

* * *

(3) James Denoyer

James Denoyer

Denoyer is assumed to have disappeared his uncle and another old guy. While the two old guys disappeared, a drop-fall drunk named Baumeister was working at Denoyer's starving horse ranch near Westport. Baumeister just got arrested again the other day for drunk in public, as he often does. Has any badged anyone ever bothered to talk to Baumeister about Denoyer while he's in jail?

* * *

IT'S A TIRED cliche in lib circles that you get the justice you pay for. If you can't afford a private attorney, bring your toothbrush to court with you because you are mos def going to jail. In the above matters, all three suspects lawyered right up — Matson with the formidable criminal defense attorney, the late Richard Petersen out of Fort Bragg; Denoyer was privately represented for the fumbled case brought against him, not for murder, but for neglect of his horses. (The animal battalions were of course much more concerned with the horses than they were with the two old guys who suddenly weren't in Westport anymore.) And Keegan quickly went out and hired himself ace criminal defense man, Keith Faulder, an odd expense for an innocent healing professional. Faulder has since been elevated to the Superior Court while Keegan has retained the equivalently capable, and probably more expensive, Chris Andrian of Sonoma County.

* * *

Readers Remind Us…

Another Baffling Case From The Cold Case Files

The cold case double murder of Charles “Buzzy” Mitchell and his son, Nolan Mitchell, on Halloween night, October 31, 2004, at their home on Orr Springs Road, ranks right up there in the list of Mendocino County’s great unsolved murders.

Charles “Buzzy” Mitchell, then 66, died outside his house of blunt force trauma to his head and body, according to the Mendocino County Sheriff’s Office.

Nolan Mitchell, then 34, was shot to death while he slept inside the home. Nolan had been shot more than once in his upper torso.

Both men were members of the Coyote Valley Band of Pomo Indians. Charles was running for tribal office, and had been politically active up to the time of his death — particularly about controversial tribal land development issues.

The double murder followed a raid by federal agents in May, 2004. Scores of law enforcement agents descended on the Coyote Valley Band of Pomo Indians reservation and casino, seizing computers and documents in search of evidence of embezzlement and other tribal corruption.

Ultimately, eight leaders of the Coyote Valley Pomo tribe, including former Chairwoman Priscilla Hunter, pleaded guilty to one misdemeanor count of willful failure to file tax returns.

Federal prosecutors originally had filed more than two dozen criminal counts against Hunter. They included multiple counts of conspiracy to steal and misapply tribal and casino funds; willful misappropriation of casino funds; obstruction of justice; tax evasion; and failure to file tax returns.

The original charges against Hunter carried a sentence of up to 225 years in prison and more than $28 million in fines.

Tribal members, including Buzzy and Nolan Mitchell, contended that Hunter and other council members took more than $1 million from the tribe. Federal authorities did not release a figure.

Federal prosecutors also alleged the former tribal leaders illegally charged at least $40,000 to tribal credit cards and illegally donated more than $35,000 to politicians and political committees.

They were alleged to have spent more than $6,000 on personal items and bought $45,000 worth of first-class airline tickets, in violation of tribal rules. — John Sakowicz

* * *

There seem to be too many criminal cases unsolved, or still under investigation in this county. I wonder why the Turner family, obviously victims in their case, would stay mum on that incident at their camp—bad for tourism? Or something more embarrassing.? Obviously, the case involves the issue of public safety out in the woods. Their silence seems irresponsible.

Then there is the mysterious death of Ann Shapiro, early last year, Little River resident, whose lifeless body was found near the beach in the north end of town [Fort Bragg]. Ruled a ‘suspicious death’, not suicide. She had checked herself into an Ortner facility in Willits, due to extreme depression, but left the next morning at 5am. Without a car, she ended up dead in Fort Bragg early that afternoon. I don’t have time to check on the dates, but about a week later, that nightmarish home invasion/knife attack, by a Montana maniac, shook us all to the core. He was on the Most Wanted list in that state btw…was Shapiro an earlier target? — Alice Chouteau

* * *

Don’t forget the MRC forester, a man named Grant, who disappeared without a trace a couple of years ago while apparently eating his lunch on the North Navarro Headlands. — George Hollister

* * *

And the young Australian girl who walked out of the little restaurant north of Point Arena never to be seen again. Too many bad things happen in our rural paradise, but so long as you stick to surface appearances Mendocino County seems almost normal. — Bruce Anderson

6 Responses to "Cold Case Files"

  1. Derek Hoyle   March 29, 2017 at 5:56 pm

    Concerning number 3: One of those “old guys” you so casually dismiss, was David V. Neily, quite a nice man.

    I met him long ago when I lived on the ridge above Anchor Bay, he was friendly, intelligent, and handy, could fix anything, he had many great stories, and was someone you always remember.

    The evidence pointed to foul play, yet the S.O. really bungled the investigation, it’s tragic that these two (apparent) murders are going unsolved.

    I have a friend who knew the still missing, Eric Grant, and he’s said for years, “You really don’t want to go missing in Mendocino County, because you’ll never be found.”

    Reply
    • Lisa M. Neily   December 2, 2019 at 12:55 am

      Thank you Derek for what you said about my dad.

      Reply
  2. Bruce Anderson   March 30, 2017 at 5:53 am

    Certainly didn’t intend to sound dismissive. The AVA’s the only publication in the area to devote sustained attention to the Denoyer case. In fairness to the Sheriff’s Department, they also devoted much time and attention to the missing men. I know there were several painstaking searches of not only Denoyer’s “ranch,” but the surrounding area. On one all-day occasion cadaver dogs scoured the nearby hills. Only yesterday I happened to talk with a deputy on another matter, but took the opportunity to mention a fellow named Baumeister who also worked at Denoyer’s ranch at the time the men went missing. Baumeister is frequently arrested in Ukiah for drunk in public. I told the deputy I hoped investigators were talking to him about the Denoyer case while he’s in custody. Of all these cases, the most frustrating to me is the Keegan matter. There’s more than enough evidence pointing at Dr. Keegan as his wife’s killer to indict him for her murder, but almost 7 years down the line no indictment.

    Reply
  3. Karyn Feiden   March 30, 2017 at 10:26 pm

    Thanks for keeping the candle burning on the Susan Keegan case, Bruce.

    For more than six years, the DA’s office has proclaimed that Susan Keegan’s murder is being actively investigated. The crime has been officially acknowledged as such, with a death certificate that reads “homicide.”

    As recently as a year ago, a search warrant was finally executed on Norm Rosen, the Ukiah divorce mediator who had been working with Susan and Peter Keegan. Rosen had witnessed Dr. Keegan going “ballistic” in his office when financial terms were being discussed.

    Every law enforcement official who has looked at this case agrees there is only one suspect. But no jury has heard the evidence against him, and the anguish of absent justice remains.

    DA Eyster won’t return calls to the family, which has dared to ask loudly why no prosecution has occurred. So we are grateful to the media, and especially the feisty AVA, for reminding the community of the harm that is done when due process is neglected.

    Susan — writer, actor, artist, advocate, mother, sister, cousin, and friend — deserved better, and so do the taxpayers of Mendocino County.

    Read more: http://www.justice4susan.com.

    Reply
  4. George Dorner   October 17, 2019 at 12:39 pm

    And there’s a few dozen more such cases not covered here. It’s just that Mr. Anderson is publishing a newspaper, not a book, and doesn’t have room for the rest.

    Reply
  5. George J. Dorner   December 2, 2019 at 2:00 pm

    While researching the Neily case for Websleuths.com, I discovered something I thought very interesting. James Denoyer had virtually no online listings–less than just about anyone I have ever researched. It leads me to wonder if Mr. Denoyer is a resident of the Witness Protection Program.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.